How to Stop Overthinking Small Decisions

The biggest decision of my life was made on gut, not on analysis.

Small ones used to take me far longer than they were worth.

That sounds like it should be the other way round. It is not, and working out why is what stopped small decisions costing me so much.

Why the Small Ones Cost More Than the Big Ones

A big decision gets treated like a big decision. You give it time. You talk to someone. You accept that it is hard, so the difficulty does not feel like a personal failing.

Small decisions get none of that. Nobody sits down to properly consider a sandwich.

So when a small one takes far longer than it should, there is no explanation available except the obvious one. Something must be wrong with you.

That is the real cost. Not the lost minutes. The quiet conclusion you draw about yourself afterwards, several times a day, for years.

And there are hundreds of them. Which reply to send. Which route to drive. Whether to say something in the group chat. Each one is tiny. Together they are most of your mental life.

What Is Actually Happening When You Cannot Pick

Here is my honest read, and it took me a long time to see it.

When I could not pick, I was not weighing anything up. I had already weighed it up. I knew both options were fine.

I was waiting for a feeling to arrive. The feeling of being sure.

Until that turned up, picking felt like guessing, and guessing felt dangerous. So I went round again, looking for one more piece of information that would settle it.

That information does not exist. There is no fact about lunch that produces certainty.

This is the same thing I write about in trusting your gut instead of overthinking, just shrunk down to something small enough that you never examine it.

The Certainty You Are Waiting For Is a Feeling

This is the bit that changed things for me.

Certainty is not information. It is a feeling, in the same family as comfort and safety. And like any feeling, it can be let go of.

You cannot think your way into it. You have been trying that, which is why the loop runs so long.

Underneath the need to be sure, there is usually a want. Approval, if the decision involves other people. Control, if it involves anything you cannot predict. Security, if getting it wrong would cost you something.

Once you see which one is driving it, the decision stops being about the sandwich.

I go through the mechanics of releasing a feeling properly in how I let go of negative thoughts and feelings every day. It is the same move, done in about twenty seconds.

What I Do When I Catch Myself Looping

Three steps, in this order. The order is the whole thing.

Notice the tightness. There is a physical feeling before there is a thought. Chest or stomach, usually. Catching it is easier than catching the thought, because the thought sounds reasonable and the tightness does not.

Let it be there. Do not argue with it. Do not tell yourself it is silly to feel tense about a sandwich. Just find where it is and stay with it for a few breaths. It fades faster than you expect, because there was never much fuel in it.

Then ask what actually happens if I get this wrong. Not what could go wrong. What actually happens. The honest answer for a small decision is almost always some mild inconvenience for about an hour.

Then pick. Usually the picking is easy by that point, because you were never stuck on the options.

Notice what is not in that list. I am not telling you to think about it harder, and I am not telling you to reframe the thought into something more positive. Reframing a thought you have not released is suppression wearing a nicer outfit. It works for about a minute.

Why Cutting Down Your Choices Only Half Works

Most advice on this says the same thing. Have fewer options. Eat the same breakfast. Wear a uniform. Batch your decisions.

I think that genuinely helps, and I do some of it. Fewer choices means fewer chances to loop.

But I want to be honest about what it is doing. It is removing the situations that trigger the problem. It is not touching the problem.

You cannot remove every choice from your life. The ones that are left are usually the ones that matter more, which means the loop turns up exactly where it is most expensive.

So use the routines. Just do not mistake a tidier life for a settled one.

The Strange Thing About Big Decisions

The biggest decision of my life was made almost entirely on gut.

My wife and I had just got married. We both quit our jobs and went travelling for six months, with no real plan beyond that. It is still the biggest risk I have ever taken.

It was not a confident decision. It was a leap of faith, and we took it together. She quit her job too, at the same time, which meant it was not only mine to get wrong.

I have thought about why that one was clearer than the small ones. My honest read is that the stakes were so obviously high that I stopped pretending a right answer existed. There was nothing to look up. So I stopped looking, and felt for it instead.

Small decisions let you keep pretending. There is always one more thing you could check.

What Changed When I Stopped Performing

My version of people-pleasing was not struggling to say no. It was performing. Being whoever I thought the room wanted, agreeable and entertaining on their terms.

When I stopped, something I did not expect happened. I started making decisions much faster.

It makes sense looking back. A lot of my small decisions were not decisions at all. They were calculations about how the choice would land with other people.

Take the audience out and there is far less to work out. I wrote about the rest of that shift in how to stop people-pleasing.

I should say I have not fixed this. I still stall on things where I care what someone will think of the answer. It is quicker to spot now, and I no longer treat it as evidence of anything.

What to Try This Week

One thing, not a system.

The next time you catch yourself on the second lap of a small decision, stop and notice where it sits in your body. Stay there for three breaths. Then pick whichever option you were leaning towards when you started.

You will get some of them wrong. That is the point. Getting a small decision wrong is how you find out that getting a small decision wrong costs almost nothing.

Self-belief is not a feeling you wait for. It is evidence you build, and this is a cheap way to build some. That is the same argument I make in the 20-minute rule, applied to something that takes seconds instead of twenty minutes.

If the looping is loud enough that it is running most of your day, that is worth taking seriously rather than pushing through. It is what overthinking and decision coaching is for, and if it comes with anxiety that is affecting how you function, please speak to your GP as well. What I do here sits alongside professional support, never instead of it.

Common Questions